Several times per movie, the podcast will do an All-Star week, with a new guest every day of the week. This is a departure from the standard format where a guest takes a block of five minutes to analyze, scrutinize, and celebrate. All-Star weeks allow the show to fit more guests in the finite number of minutes available. All-Star weeks sometimes take on a theme, such as:
- Listener All-Stars (Minutes 121–123 of The Empire Strikes Back, technically not the full week.)
- Cartoonist All-Stars (Minutes 56–60 of Return of the Jedi)
- L.A. All-Stars (Minutes 96–100 of Return of the Jedi)
- Podcasting All-Stars (Minutes 101–105 of Return of the Jedi)
- Movies by Minutes All-Stars (Minutes 16–20 of Attack of the Clones)
All-Star weeks are also a chance to honor those listeners who support the show throughout the hiatus. Beginning with the ROTJ–TPM hiatus, Pete randomly draws the names of 5 patreon supporters from a digital hat to be guests on the show.
- Minutes 91–95 of The Phantom Menace
- Minutes 116–120 of Attack of the Clones
- Minutes 126–130 of Revenge of the Sith
- Minutes 86–90 of The Force Awakens
For a list of of guests who appear in an All-Star week, see All-Star guests.